Comparison of poietic system characteristics


Most recent substantive changes:
Dec 5, 2000

AUTOPOIETIC SYSTEMS

   

SYMPOIETIC SYSTEMS

Defining Characteristics

   

 

self-producing

   

collectively producing

self-produced boundaries

   

lacking boundaries

organizationally closed

   

organizationally ajar

external structural coupling

   

internal and external structural coupling

Characteristic Tendencies

   

 

autonomous units

   

complex, amorphous entities

central control

   

distributed control

'packaged,' same information

   

distributed, different information

reproduction by copy

   

amorphous reproduction

evolution between systems

   

evolution within system

growth/development oriented

   

evolutionary orientation

homeostatic balance

   

balance by dynamic tension

steady state

   

potentially dramatic, surprising change

finite temporal trajectories

   

potentially infinite temporal trajectories

predictable

   

unpredictable

Advantages/disadvantages

   

 

efficient

   

adaptable, flexible

constrained, codified information

   

open to new and different information

require certainty

   

ok with surprise

Slightly adapted from: Dempster, Beth "Sympoietic and autopoietic systems: A new distinction for self-organizing systems" in Proceedings of the World Congress of the Systems Sciences and ISSS 2000, J.K. Allen and J. Wilby, eds. [Presented at the International Society for Systems Studies Annual Conference, Toronto, Canada, July 2000] - abstract - pdf file -